Showing posts with label Globalization. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Globalization. Show all posts

Sunday, October 18, 2026

Erosion of Architectural Types

 The project of modernity was, in part, a project of liberation: from tradition, from the load-bearing wall, from fixed plans and from inherited forms of construction. Architecture sought greater freedom to organise space according to the new social and technological possibilities of the twentieth century, shaped by—and, in part, demanded by—the post war socialist project.

Yet the freedom gained from these constraints produced another kind of constraint. As architecture became detached from the social institutions, civic structures and state that had helped generate architectural types, generic buildings became easier to transfer from use value to exchange value. Homes, workplaces and civic buildings could increasingly be abstracted from their particular uses and reduced to as transactional “assets”. What began as a liberation from construction gradually became a constraint of finance.

The story that follows is therefore not simply one of technological progress or architectural style. It is a story of how one form of freedom created the conditions for another system of constraint: from construction to flexibility, from flexibility to genericity, and ultimately from genericity to financial viability.

THE GIFT OF PROMETHEUS // FROM CONSTRUCTION TO GENERIC:

The terrace, courtyard house, townhouse, mansion block and mews were not simply formal inventions. They emerged from combinations of structure, climate, land, culture and patterns of inhabitation. The type was knowledge accumulated into form. Before the modern structural frame, construction and architectural type were deeply intertwined. The masonry wall determined the depth of the building, the size of openings, the relationship between rooms and the way buildings met the street. Construction generated architecture.

Dom-Ino disrupted this relationship. By separating structure from enclosure, it made the plan potentially free: walls could move, façades could become independent and interiors could be reorganised without fundamentally altering the structural system. What had once been a specific architectural type could increasingly become a generic container.

But this liberation did not begin with Dom-Ino. The elevator had already begun to transform the economics of the city. In 1853, Elisha Graves Otis introduced the safety brake that made passenger elevators viable; in 1857, the first permanent Otis passenger elevator was installed at the E.V. Haughwout Building in New York. The elevator did more than liberate the city from height. It transformed height into value. By making upper floors accessible, it allowed a fixed plot of land to support an expanding quantity of rentable or saleable space. Chicago and New York became laboratories for this new vertical economy, as technological advances and rapidly rising land values encouraged increasingly tall buildings. The elevator therefore removed not only a physical ceiling but an economic one. Once height could be converted into value, the limit was no longer the plot but how high capital could build.

The structural frame extended this transformation from the scale of the city to that of the building. If the elevator made vertical accumulation possible, the frame made the resulting volume increasingly flexible: structure could be separated from enclosure, plans reorganised and façades detached from the logic of load-bearing construction. The subsequent development of reinforced concrete, steel frames, mechanical systems and curtain walls intensified this separation. Structural grids could be repeated, services concentrated and envelopes applied independently. From Berlin to Beijing, London to Riyadh, buildings could increasingly be produced through variations of the same underlying proposition: grid, core, slab and envelope.

This is where Rem Koolhaas's Generic City becomes significant. Writing in the 1990s, Koolhaas recognised that globalisation was producing cities increasingly detached from the burdens of history, identity and particularity. The Generic City was not simply an accusation of architectural sameness; it was an attempt to understand a new urban condition in which genericity itself became an advantage.

THE TROJAN HORSE // FROM GENERIC TO AN ASSET

As cities became increasingly integrated into global systems of finance, property became more than a physical necessity. It became a principal vehicle through which capital could be stored, invested and reproduced. Reinier de Graaf has written extensively about this transformation, particularly the position of real estate within contemporary capitalism. The building acquires a second identity: not simply as a place, but as an asset.

A home, office or hotel can simultaneously be land value, an income stream, collateral, an investment product or a development opportunity. Once architecture enters this financial system, its characteristics are evaluated through a different vocabulary: floor area, efficiency, yield, rental value, construction cost, finance, risk and residual land value.

The present day shell-and-core building is the perfect expression of this condition. Its value lies in its neutrality: a structural frame, core, envelope and basic services can be delivered without determining precisely who will occupy it or how it will ultimately be configured. That neutrality makes the building transferable. It can be sold, leased, fitted out, subdivided, reconfigured or converted. The more standardised the floorplate, the easier it becomes to price, compare and finance.

The separation of structure from architecture produced the flexible building. Globalisation extended this logic into the generic city. Financialization discovered the value of buildings that could be transferred, adapted and reproduced with relatively little friction. The free plan became the flexible floorplate; the generic building became the financial asset. The building becomes something that can be modelled financially before it is built. And this changes architectural selection.

THE CURSE OF MIDAS // FROM ASSET TO VIABILITY

No one needs to outlaws the terrace, abolish the courtyard house or declare the mansion block obsolete. Land value, construction cost, finance, yield and risk quietly decide what gets built. A type that requires more circulation, a less efficient floorplate or more complex construction becomes harder to finance—and eventually harder to build. Nothing is prohibited. It is simply made unviable. This is the market’s quiet “coercion”: it does not tell architecture what it cannot be. It determines what can afford to exist.

Nothing is prohibited. It is simply priced out of existence. This may be one of the most powerful force shaping the contemporary city because it operates without appearing to make an architectural decision.

HOUSE OF CARDS // WHAT DO WE LOSE?

Consider the terrace. Its value does not lie simply in the repetition of individual houses, but in the relationship between party walls, front doors, gardens, street frontage and density. Courtyard housing, mews, perimeter blocks and mansion blocks similarly derive much of their value from relationships between building, street and collective space. These forms are not necessarily inefficient. They are simply efficient according to a different logic.

That distinction matters because the development model can privilege the measurable efficiency of the generic floorplate over qualities whose value is distributed across the urban whole. When that happens repeatedly, types can disappear without ever being declared obsolete. The financial model has therefore become an architectural editor. It does not merely determine whether something can be built; it increasingly influences what kind of building is worth building.

Can a courtyard compete with the tower? Can a terrace achieve contemporary densities? Can the perimeter block, mansion block or mews be made compatible with contemporary construction and finance? More fundamentally, can the value of a street, a threshold, a garden or a particular relationship between public and private space be recognised when it does not translate neatly into a development appraisal?

Perhaps this is the deeper tragedy of the contemporary city. The problem is no longer simply that certain forms are unfashionable or inefficient. The economic system increasingly determines the limits of architectural possibility and imagination before architecture even begins.

SISYPHUS // END OF HISTORY

The trajectory from Dom-Ino to the Generic City and finally to the financially optimised building is therefore not simply a history of technology or style. It is a history of increasing abstraction: first architecture from structure, then the city from place, and finally the building from architecture itself.

Here Manfredo Tafuri’s (Architecture and Utopia: Design and Capitalist Development 1976) darker reading of modernity becomes relevant. For Tafuri, architecture’s heroic claim to transform society increasingly collided with the realities of ever assimilating Capitalist development. Its critical ambitions were absorbed into the very system it sought to challenge. What appeared as architectural freedom could become another instrument of production.

The load-bearing wall constrained architecture; the modern frame liberated it. Globalisation made genericity desirable. Capital made it profitable. And perhaps, in Tafuri’s terms, this is where architecture confronts its own “end of history”: not the disappearance of architecture, but the exhaustion of its claim to produce radically different possibilities outside the logic of the market and in service of society.

 Architecture escaped the constraints of construction only to encounter the constraints of capital.

Friday, September 04, 2026

Post Babel: Death of Craftsman

One of the important texts in the history of modern architecture is Adolf Loos’s “Ornament and Crime,” written in 1908. Loos argued that ornament had become unnecessary — and, more importantly, that it represented a waste of human labour, material and time. Architecture should no longer be burdened by the decorative traditions of the past simply because they had been inherited from previous generations.

His argument can be understood through five central ideas:

1. Ornament was economically wasteful. Decorative details required additional labour, craftsmanship and material without necessarily improving the function of an object or building. For Loos, this was not merely an aesthetic problem; it was an economic one. A society should not continue investing enormous amounts of labour into things whose primary purpose was decoration.

2. Ornament represented an earlier stage of civilisation. Loos suggested that as societies developed, their need for decoration diminished. The modern individual should not need to surround themselves with elaborate ornament in order to express status, identity or cultural sophistication.

3. Architecture needed to respond to modern life. The world in which Loos was writing was changing rapidly. Cities were expanding, industrial production was transforming economies, new materials were becoming available and objects were increasingly being manufactured rather than individually crafted. Architecture could no longer simply reproduce the visual language of the past.

4. Architectural quality did not require decoration: Architecture could derive its richness from proportion, space, material, construction and composition, rather than from applying ornament as a superficial layer.

5. Architecture should express its own time. A modern society equipped with modern technologies and new systems of production should not continue dressing its buildings in the architectural language of previous centuries.

What I find particularly interesting about Ornament and Crime is it sits at a fascinating moment in history when industrialisation was fundamentally changing the relationship between society, production and the things we used every day.

The emergence of mass production created an entirely different logic. Instead of producing an individually crafted chair, lamp, door handle or building component through hours of skilled labour, industry could increasingly produce thousands of identical objects efficiently and cheaply. Standardisation became an economic advantage. Repetition became a virtue rather than a deficiency.

In that context, Loos's rejection of ornament aligned remarkably well with the emerging industrial economy.

• The simpler the object, the easier it was to standardise.
• The more standardised it became, the easier it was to manufacture.
• The easier it was to manufacture, the more widely it could be distributed.

And suddenly, architecture was no longer simply about designing individual buildings. It became part of a much larger transformation in which the entire material environment of society could be designed, manufactured and distributed at scale.

These principles eventually proliferated into furniture, interiors, products, graphics, transportation, appliances and virtually every other aspect of the designed environment. The modern world increasingly became a world of standardised objects: chairs, lights, windows, kitchens, cars, telephones, appliances and eventually entire building systems. Thus rejection of ornament therefore became intertwined with something much bigger: the industrialisation of design itself.

Architecture moved away from the idea of the building as a unique, handcrafted object and towards the idea of the building as something that could be rationalised, systematised and potentially mass-produced.

And here, for me, lies the great irony. Loos was attacking ornament partly because he saw it as a symbol of wasted labour — yet his rejection of ornament arrived at precisely the moment when industrial capitalism was developing the capacity to produce the material world at unprecedented scale.

What began as a cultural and architectural critique of ornament consequently became part of a much larger transformation in the relationship between architecture, technology, economics and society. There is something almost paradoxical about this trajectory.

Loos was, in many ways, arguing for less: less decoration, less waste, less unnecessary labour, less attachment to the past. Industrial modernity took that principle and turned it into more: more objects, more buildings, more production, more consumption and ultimately more of the same designed environment reproduced across society.

In parallel, Walter Benjamin’s The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction, written in the 1930s, looks at a related transformation, but from the perspective of art rather than architecture. His concern was not simply that technology could reproduce artworks; it was that mechanical reproduction fundamentally changed what an artwork was, how it was experienced and what gave it its cultural authority.

The consequence was not simply that there were more images. It was that the relationship between production and consumption had fundamentally changed. The artwork no longer necessarily needed to be experienced as a unique object created through the hand of an individual maker. It could become an image, a reproduction, a commodity and a mass cultural experience. And I think this is where Benjamin's argument begins to speak directly to architecture.

Because architecture was undergoing a remarkably similar transformation- of the building itself was increasingly becoming detached from the individual act of making it.

• The craftsman was gradually replaced by the industrial worker.
• The workshop was replaced by the factory.
• The individually made component was replaced by the standardised product.
• The knowledge accumulated through generations of making was increasingly separated from the person who designed the building.
• A building could now be conceived in one place, documented in another, manufactured somewhere else and assembled by hundreds of people who might never have met the architect — or even understood the building as a complete work.

This was an extraordinary gain in productive capacity. But it also represented a profound cultural loss.

The medieval or traditional craftsman was not simply a pair of hands executing somebody else's instructions. Their knowledge was embedded in the material itself: knowing how stone fractures, how timber behaves, how a joint should be made, how ornament relates to structure, how a particular material should be handled. The act of making was itself a form of knowledge.

In this sense, I see the crisis of modern architecture as part of the same crisis Benjamin identified in art. Mechanical reproduction did not merely change the appearance of things; it changed our relationship with the act of making them. Architecture, perhaps more than almost any other discipline, embodies this contradiction. Modernism gave us extraordinary possibilities: standardisation, efficiency, affordability, new materials, new construction techniques and the possibility of providing better environments to millions of people rather than a privileged few. But the same process also progressively displaced the craftsman from the centre of architectural production.

The building became a product of systems rather than the expression of a continuous chain of human making. And perhaps this is the deeper story behind the transition from ornament to modernity.

We often tell the history of Modernism as a story of liberation — liberation from historical styles, unnecessary decoration and outdated conventions. And there is truth in that. But I think it can also be understood as a story of displacement.

We displaced ornament. Then we displaced craft. Then we displaced the craftsman. And replaced them with an alienated workforce, separated from the material, process and final product of their own labour.

And perhaps that is the real crisis that both Loos and Benjamin, in very different ways, help us see: the transformation of culture from something made through human hands and embedded in particular places into something that could be reproduced, standardised and distributed at scale across the globe (goods, services and labour).

Architecture did not escape the crisis of mechanical reproduction. It became one of its largest and most permanent expressions. The modern environment was no longer simply designed. It was manufactured.


Thursday, May 25, 2023

Gentrification panel 04

Past 4 decades of liberalisation has led us to where we are, privatised water supply sector that is dumping sewage in waterways, privatised energy providers profiteering from energy crisis, a liberalised housing market that has amplified the housing affordability and access crisis, a privatised railway network that prioritises dividends over investments, an NHS that is slowly being privatised through underfunding of the public component, a private postal service, a privatised educational sector that further increases disparity and polarisation. 

Is this conversation within the scope of an architect / planners / sustainability expert? We write long reports on textures, colours, placemaking..."happiness" even and yet we skirt the very foundations that exert direct influence on our lives.


An article on Canary Wharf and the tax break it received from the state.

Gentrification panel 03


 

Monday, March 20, 2023

Sustainability and Resilience

The IPCC's "Final Warning" on Climate Change...

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/mar/20/ipcc-climate-crisis-report-delivers-final-warning-on-15c

...is possibly going to increase the frequency with which Sustainability and Resilience get used in meetings, something I am bracing myself for.

My friend Raffa often says, the road to hell is paved with best intentions. Like the movie "Don’t look Up" there is an impending catastrophe that we can see but the only opportunity of expression that our professions (so finely tuned to existing economic structure) affords is that of paper pushing bureaucrats. Every point of urgency captured into yet another aspect of the built environment to be quantified from embodied carbon to number of plastic bags a farmer in rural Vietnam uses...or Advocacy of small tweaks to planning policy, small enough to not threaten status quo but big enough for all round chest bumps on small change - big wins pretenses.

Meanwhile:

World's richest 1% cause double CO2 emissions of poorest 50%, says Oxfam
Just 100 companies responsible for 71% of global emissions
Historical climate emissions reveal responsibility of big polluting nations
Super-rich’s carbon investment emissions ‘equivalent to whole of France
more than 90% of rainforest carbon offsets by biggest certifier are worthless 
Urban water crises driven by elites’ unsustainable consumption


This illustrates Climate and Sustainability aren't Technocratic issues they are political and tied to access and redistribution of resources. If we have to be constructive and start somewhere, it is within Politics + Economy.

Update // received "watching my paper straw dissolve in my coffee while..." meme today that captures my post rather well.

Friday, March 03, 2023

Restaurant Reviews and Architecture

Brilliant review on NOMA’s closure by Jay Rayner, 

who seems to do something that most Architects and Planners are unable to, point to the fallacy of sustainability as being a purely technocratic process of quantification and mitigation rather than an honest political discourse.

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/jan/15/twenty-six-courses-400-bills-artichoke-creme-brulee-i-wont-miss-fine-dining

“We dream of a future in which the chef is socially engaged, conscious of and responsible for his or her contribution to a just, sustainable society,” it began, somehow failing to acknowledge that their job was making dinner for rich people. In truth, however hard you attend to your restaurant’s sustainability, it’s pointless if most of your customers are flying business class to get there or travelling in chauffeured limos from Manhattan because those are the only ones who can afford it. The carbon footprint of the people you attract becomes part of the carbon footprint of your business.

+

Reiner de Graaf writing in Dezeen marking the launch of his third book

https://www.dezeen.com/2023/02/28/reinier-de-graaf-architecture-buzzwords-archispeak-opinion/

Both disconnected individuals, one is restaurant reviewer and food critic, other an architect / partner in a global commercial practise...embedded within the current state of affairs, so definitely not outliers...yet they capture a common strand.

Advocacy, the convoluted bureaucracy of quantification and absolute mind numbing cacophony of positive intentions...serving only one purpose, obfuscation and social condensation...a pressure release valve.

The hypocrisy of it all.


Wednesday, September 04, 2019

Stupid Cities_Part 2

Politics of Obsolescence: Planned Obsolescence is an integral part of consumer society, stretching from the Phoebus cartel of 1925 to present day marketing strategies adopted by car giants and tech companies. A planned obsolescence of technology in cars, mobiles, operating systems maintains a gradual stream of consumers. This when asserted on cities leads to a trend of steel and concrete buildings in cities like London, New York, Chicago having an average life span of 40 years, not necessarily due to material deterioration but instead opportunities arsing from speculation, facilitating wealth creation by increasing density over city spaces.

Kit of Parts: With modular technology, 3d fabrication and Smart city technology, our increasingly Smart buildings are moving away from being buildings built to last, but instead gadget-like that can be changed, retrofitted, upgraded. New innovations in timber construction and prefabricated modules allows for quick ways to not only construct but also dismantle buildings, bringing the building industry within this sphere of obsolescence. In such a speculative fast changing landscape it is only natural that most clients adopt Flexibility as their motto. If buildings are turning into gadgets, then the city is increasingly resembling a motherboard which mitigates and provides flexibility for each component and sustains its “pay as you go” citizens. Is this Fukuyama's physical manifestation of End of History? where as a human race we no longer have ability to design and deliver even institutional buildings that are solid?

As professionals of built environment, we must be clear, we do not make gadgets, we make buildings that displace air, cast shadows and influence space. It is this awareness that will make us take design decisions with greater sense of responsibility, thought and consideration.

Note: above is a summary of an ongoing discussion with my colleague and friend Konstantinos Dimitrantzos.

Saturday, August 03, 2019

Stupid Cities_Part 1

While the technological components of Smart City and what each technological system can do is impressive, the representation of space and form of Smart Cities is increasingly caricatured, with a generic axonometric image stamped with icons, Wi-Fi symbols and acronyms. Following that is a long description on IoTs, Servers, Networks, real time mitigation of services and everyone’s favourite autonomous vehicles, yet there is no specificity to this technology’s influence on form and space.
The two big technological advancements, electricity and the internet were able to seep seamlessly into oldest of the old city cores from gothic quarter of Barcelona to Beijing without asserting a direct impact/influence on the urban form and space! So if someone is going to claim that a bunch of IoT devices and real time data flows are going to shape urban form and space ("in ways we have never imagined!"...all explained on ppt with black slides and vague Matrix like graphics that don't mean zilch)....we should insist on what does it look like???!!!
One exception that has had an impact on urban space is the invention of automobiles. In which case, Frank Lloyd Wright was able to interpret his image of a new city influenced by the technology of the automobile in the form of Broadacre City. 
Which again brings us to what does it look like?!

Sunday, December 03, 2017

Europan 14_Sluisbuurt: Landscape of Making

Some additional material from Europan 14 
Site: Sluisbuurt, Amsterdam, Netherlands
Design brief: Productive City
Design title: Landscape of Making
Project work done in collaboration with Chris Cornelissen







Saturday, May 31, 2014

Doha (26th - 31st May)







 

Having worked on various projects located in Doha over the past 5 years, it is only recently that I had the opportunity to visit it. It being a short trip we had just enough time to visit a new development called Katara and Souk Waqif that felt like public spaces, while rest of the experience was through the car on a busy high speed road surrounded by tower (West Bay) or low rise suburban sprawl. The built environment seemed to reflect the demographics of the place where one could visibly see the difference between built forms and spaces that were for Qataris, expatriates and low skilled workers, and a conscious space planning to keep these segregated. Workers were seen to use the street or vague in-between spaces as their public space to linger in the background, almost invisible.
This contradiction of desiring segregation but aspiring for an image of public life for each of the three groups under consideration reminds me of China Mieville’s The City & The City, described here as “The City & the City takes place in the cities of Besźel and Ul Qoma. These two cities actually occupy much of the same geographical space, but via the volition of their citizens (and the threat of the secret power known as Breach), they are perceived as two different cities. A denizen of one city must dutifully 'unsee' (that is, consciously erase from their mind or fade into the background) the denizens, buildings, and events taking place in the other city – even if they are an inch away. The twin cities are composed of crosshatched, alter, and total areas. "Total" areas are entirely in one city, the city in which the observer currently resides. "Alter" areas are completely in the other city, and so must be completely avoided and ignored. Between these are areas of "crosshatch". These might be streets, parks or squares where denizens of both cities walk alongside one another, albeit "unseen." Areas that exist in both cities usually go under different names in each one. There is also Copula Hall, "one of the very few" buildings which exists in both cities under the same name. Rather than being cross-hatched, it essentially functions as a border. It is the only way in which one can legally and officially pass from one city to another. Passing through the border passage takes travellers, geographically (or "grosstopically"), to the exact place they started from – only in a different city”. Only in case of Doha it would be 3 cities interlocked within one another. For designers who don’t have the luxury of fighting social injustices or demand democracies, developing such self-indulgent design briefs is the only way to survive work in the middle east, which to be honest can be lot more interesting given the crazy money + ambition combination than do work in a democratic process with restricted budget, a 100000 page convoluted policy guidance, 1 km deep sub terrain infrastructure, public consultations and if that is not enough bunch of boring consultants who are hired to purely tick the boxes to give rise to a reasonably well reasoned masterplan that reeks of absence of any ambition for the built environment.
 

Sunday, December 09, 2012

Elephants in Bombay

1) A City Ages
City:
Mumbai over the past few years has come to be a city that is in a constant state of construction. As if the audacious concretization aspires to compete with the speed and scale of natural deterioration within the city, where built forms catch dust, moss, cracks and crumble, very often at a rate faster than the human bodies that inhabit it. Signs of age seem to climb over every object, building and person like creepers that grow slowly but with a fierce determination rooted in consciousness of the inevitable outcome.
Presently raising the FAR/FSI is seen as a solution to trigger regeneration, but I only wonder what would happen in another 40 to 50 years when these 20 to 25 storey towers grow old and are crumbling, what would be the collateral then? How would the deficit between the true cost of maintenance and affordability based on earning capacities be rationalized  What kind of maintenance model will be required if the option of raising FSI is no longer viable? Or will a constant flow of infrastructure projects allow continuous expansion? Either which ways, this dialectics of ageing and reconstruction are here to tango till the bubble bursts or life here becomes unbearably agonizing and people migrate to second tier cities.
Through this turmoil of injections of new infrastructure, new construction, old decaying fabric, the city is in a state of constant change and that too with rapid speed, making it unable for someone to completely be able to grasp or even conjecture the nature of an intermediate state it tries to evolve towards.
Most of the spaces of my childhood memories have been forgotten by the city only to be replaced by skeletal concrete monoliths that form a wall depriving the city the very symbol of future hope, the line where the sea and sky meet, the horizon.

Friends:
Most of us are now old enough to savour nostalgia, a feeling that comes when the balance between past reaches a critical limit in relation to the future, enjoying memories of what it used to be like and city that Bombay once was and how it has come to be Mumbai. The utopian optimism of being able to fight back, small intervention-big change attitude has been replaced by either proposals that are geared towards damage control (Zizek's capitalism but with a human face) or intense mapping exercises (AMO's this is the present, now and here and no use resisting it), and so interestingly most sentences in most conversation seem to start with the word "interestingly", summing up the total disconnection that professionals have from the built environment, restricted to purely being witnesses that record, re-record and represent these recording in subversive ways to balance the guilt of impotency.
Like everything else, age has caught up if not with them then with people close to them, as they try to find solutions to the state of ageing in this city.
Grandparents:
My grandmother who has crossed 85, recently moved in our home. Her frail and fragile body bears witness to this city she lived in, her entire life, Dadar Shivaji Park (1937 to 1951),Thane Charai (1951 to 1960), Goregaon Pandurangwadi (1960 to 1962), Cotton Green Kala Chowki (1963 to 1985), Mulund (1986 to 2012),Borivali (2012 onwards). Having short term memory she constantly enquires of her grandchildren once an hour which my father patiently responds to, in manner as if the question was never asked before.
My maternal grandfather lives with my aunt and struggles through with similar problems of age.
This state of vulnerability and return to innocence according to me is the most merciless but yet in some ways appropriate form of redemption to our existence, and deserves the dignity that this fast paced, aggressive city very often cannot afford.
A Thesis on old age homes:
A friend of mine, Namrata Kapoor, few years back had researched and designed an old age home as a thesis topic. One of the issues that she dealt with was the relevance of having old age and its supporting institutions within the city and and not exiled outside the city limits as is the case with lots of old age homes here. I wonder given the changes that have taken place within this city and the aggression that seem to increase exponentially with increase in density and shortage of resources, would the question of "is old age relevant to this city?" needs to be reframed as "is this city relevant for old age?"

The process/state of ageing here is not a noble one, dignified with responsibilities of holding our collective past, neither is it Clint Eastwood commanding respect and a farewell with a finale, rather it is a sad process of decay and suffering and old age only inhibiting memories...bearing witness to this nature of change to me is somewhat like asking a grandparent do you remember me and seeing their eyes desperately search for signs of recognition in your face, just as i search for fast eroding spaces from my childhood in the city of Mumbai.

2) A City comes of Age
Optimism:
As Bombay grows in infrastructure and density, amid all the chaos there seems to be a sense of optimism from some people whom i spoke to, of things changing rapidly (for good or for worse was not of much concern, but the speed), and within that rapidity one has to fish opportunity at the precise moment it jumps towards you (think of Alaskan bears catching salmon). This strange optimism only seems to be growing, as if with a little more toil, little more risk and little more compromises the battle with the city would be won; dreams, desires and aspirations fulfilled. As one of my friend back in Bombay said, over the past 1 year he can see the boom of a booming economy. 
Faith:
Another one explained that a lot of things presently seem to work purely out of good faith, like the experience of crossing a highway and having good faith in the driver that he wont run over you, while the driver having complete faith in you breaking the traffic signal and crossing from unexpected places, so his speed is slow and he is more alert than an average driver abroad. 
The complexity that Bombay shelters provides for a constant source of study, research, mapping, representation and interventions, built and unbuilt, professional and academic of various scales. the opportunities and potentials are endless..the unrest will follow..."it is only a matter of time...have faith..."

3) Elephants in the City
To me witnessing changes in Bombay is like the experience of seeing elephants in the middle of the city. One is immediately struck by awe at the magnificence of the beast, only to dwell on how the animal survives and then looking carefully at damages that the city life has done to it. It is surreal experience with certain sense of strange optimism mixed with melancholia(?). There are no absolutes here, as even elephants dissolve away in the noise and smog of the city.

Sunday, September 16, 2012

A Recent Spat

A recent spat between Chipperfield and Wolf Prix over the brief for Venice biennale  represents the contradiction that exist within our profession. There are architects who believe their contribution works towards making this world a better place, while some like me are always suspicious that we are assisting in creation of environments that will only assert and strengthen the same socio-economic hierarchy, so the true exploration of 'Common Grounds' should be represented differently.
RIBA as an institute that provides licences to architects to practise in the UK and thereby maintains quality but has very little power when it comes to the market forces that govern the price or even the size of the dwellings. According to a recent survey the dwelling sizes in many cases are as low as 77% of the recommended size. so in such cases the 'element of humanitarian effort' is often shouldered at an individualistic level, in the spirit of trying to do our best within the constraints which ofcourse comes with an asterisk of if the developer permits. These endeavours often become personal battles waged with option 1 which is more profitable and option 2,3,4 and 5 developed during late after office hours by some underpaid intern or worse, a slaving optimist, to have the opportunity to do some good. The choice of the preferred option is determined by the profitability, so option 1 wins, but there is always a warm feeling that we tried out best, and the saving grace skewed block from option 2 did get accepted in option 1. So it wasn't all that bad, we lose some we gain some...and many other self congratulatory phrases that I feel go along the lines of Zizek's anecdote on subversive politics.
To be blatantly honest as architects we have very little control over the environments we design, if the economy and market forces facilitate shoebox houses with bad light and ventilation and on the condition they start selling, we would be very soon presenting each other case studies and precedents of such "interesting high density" housing types.
A very basic preliminary survey of all the new developments taking place around London mostly due to the coalition government's policies geared towards first time buyers and faith in the idea that we can build ourselves out of recession, shows a considerable reduction in floor heights, this in itself is an excellent example of how even the best practise standards are manipulated by the market, so if an architect were to design such a residential project, he/she would ofcourse do the best one can but within the specifications of low ceiling heights as kindly requested by the developer, or if you are BIG who follow the motto Yes if More, you could reduce the height even more so that ones hair brushes against the ceiling, but with an advantage of a beautiful lush garden on the rooftop with collages of happy families enjoying the views to the city.
So what should we do? one friend suggested, "just make a choice, either this side or that". I wish it were as simple. to print my ticket to global occupy movement and become a farmer, or take refuge within academic space.
Another said think of it as subversive..with and against, fighting the system from inside, this unfortunately keeps bringing the happy Russian farmer (from Zizek's link above) to my mind...or the example of university professors who teach in Columbia but their true heart resides in Cuba. (Zizek you bastard! I was happy once!)
Though another friend who was more sympathetic to the confusions brewing in my head explained, life is like driving, if everyone drives strictly by the rules there will be accidents all around, so instead we look around, negotiate with the context and continue driving, but with an acknowledgement that contradictions do exist and we have to drive none the less, because there is no choice.
I hope by the end of our drive, atleast some of us, reach a destination that we pride in as architects living lives filled with constraints, complexities and most importantly contradictions.

Sunday, August 14, 2011

City at crossroads

While working on a regeneration project in Sao Paulo, its modernist grid, dense urban fabric and wide vehicular road network makes for obvious comparisons to New York. I have visited neither of the cities but only attempt to construct very vague ideas of them based on different media and people who do visit and narrate experiences of having been and lived there.




























One of the few things that intrigued me during the course of the project was the difference in nature of the  (Google) satellite images for New York and Sao Paulo. It isn't something that one notices immediately but I feel it could be metaphorical of the dissimilarity between the two cities. While the New York grid lies all in single plane, with every skyscraper casting its shadow at exactly the same angle as the entire city is bathed in the warm sunlight, Sao Paulo's multi coloured towers criss cross with one another to hide and reveal nooks and crevices, private courtyards, hidden pockets of lush greenery etc. The ground plane seems to modulate and fold as it attempts to balance these towers that like shards rise above in multiple directions. The schism between the overwhelming complexity of the site and an extremely advanced technology of 'eye' in the sky is apparent, as even such a technological advancement struggles to find apt representations for this particular human conglomeration. The acknowledgement of this complexity turns the satellite image into a multiple point perspective collage that attempts to voyeur into the 'local'. 
Through the course of the project these confrontational complexities within the site seemed to seep not only in the satellite imagery but also within the design, the collaborations and finally the aggressive global capital that tries to spread its roots in the fabric of the city...making the site of urban intervention an extremely contested territory with multiple points of perspective.
One of the very few projects in the professional space that I thoroughly enjoyed working on. It was very similar to the Regeneration project that I was a part of in Bombay but with only more amplified conditions of densities, dilapidation and pressure towards urban cleansing.

Thursday, August 11, 2011

Rooster's Coop

In UK
(Data from HMRC 2004-2005; incomes are before tax for individuals. The personal allowance or income tax threshold was £4,745 (people with incomes below this level did not pay income tax). The mean income was £22,800 per year with the average Briton paying £4,060 in income tax.
Above are the tax ranges, by population and the percentage they constitute. This income does not cover assets owned.)

The difference in earnings is not a gradual gradient, it reveals numbers that are highly polarised. This rather vulgar statistic with top 5 percent earning 60-70% of the income while the rest having to share from the trickle down scraps according to me is far more violent than the London riots few days back. 
A majority of rioters took to looting, as one of the article called them 'disqualified consumers' implying, they too like most of us were consumers but having lost the power to afford had been disqualified. In the absence of any support from the student unions or intellectuals in the city who have distanced themselves from this underclass, the only form of mass unrest possible will be the one with no structure, no intent and no meaning....in complete contradiction to the student protests that took place few months back. This contradiction makes it even more important for the two groups to come together...
While David Cameron made a speech filled with hate, and the opposition Labour leader Ed Miliband seemed to be weighing words completely based on popular public opinion, one person out there somewhere makes complete sense of what happened and why...below is the video of the interview.
In such a scenario I often find myself agreeing with Kostas's argumentum baculinum solutions.

Saturday, August 06, 2011

Eye in the Sky

Sometimes while working as professionals designing urban spaces, operating from democratic regions, we often find ourselves designing for regions with dictatorships where mass congregation, demonstrations, spaces of expression are often seen as threats. But still funnily the standards of design and basic Kevin Lynchian assumptions of urban space are uniformly laid out on the site, having ideas of path, edge, node etc all in place matterless of if the site is located in UK, China or Libya. Maybe because this framework seems to be most apolitical and has the necessary simplicity of rationalizing the design without getting into the socio-cultural aspects that may only give rise to 'unnecessary' contradictions that a multinational design office may not be able to reconcile (though examples of designing a military camp for a dictatorial regime after clearing a part of virgin rain forest and getting platinum sustainability ratings for the development are in abundance).
But it would be certainly interesting to see if the arrangement of infrastructure or city forms can be indicative of the nature of administration that 'manages' the region. In other words do cities in Libya or Saudi Arabia show spatial signs of a dictatorial regimes? while cities in India or UK bear witness to democracies? And if not then why is it that the nature of contemporary urban spaces under different systems of governance is more or less the same?
Ofcourse, attempt to understand city geographies through purely satellite images is dangerous but one cannot ignore the difference in the satellite image of Detroit, Venice, Delhi or London is obvious enough to use only this as the most basic tool to start off for now
(At the same time one has to accept the stark similarity of city design and planning of new redeveloped areas across the globe...as if there is some process of homogenisation).
Infrastructure Grid:
(image of Nasa earth at night)
On TED talks, Paul Romer's analysis of NASA's Earth at night composite image and how the visible light grid of different regions could be seen as an indication of development facilitated by different administrations. It does not show the nature of governance but certainly provides one a broad overview of the scale and intensity of developments in different regions.
For further detailed urban light spectrum analysis see here.
Axes and Nodes:
In an article titled 'Roundabouts and Revolution: The "Arab Street" Begins and Ends in a Circle' talks about how the traffic circle becomes the most looked after 'open' spaces in regions where mass congregation of people is seen as a threat. But the author optimistically points to how these circles have become the very stages of demonstration.
Interestingly if one were to overlay this analysis on Canary Wharf development in London one can clearly see how the central axes leads from nowhere to nowhere, spanning between two traffic circles. Providing the area with sufficient road infrastructure to provide police access to control demonstrators. This does not really dilute the argument of spatial configuration and governance rather it poses the question why is there such a stark similarity in the spatial configuration of spaces of dictatorial regimes and a Financial Centre in a democracy?
Maybe the architecture of axes and nodes is designed around easy accessibility and readability of the 'local' enabling some kind of centralised consolidated power either financial, imperial, dictatorial or any other form of totalitarian authority to control a geography.
Water:
In Greece the tax authorities are using satellite images to catch tax evading rich elites in Athens suburbs through swimming pools. An article here states "Using satellite photos, the tax authority examined the claim of the residents of Athens's wealthy suburbs and discovered that, rather than the 324 swimming pools claimed by the locals, there were 16,974 of them". This may not be indicative of governance but certainly wealth distribution.
Interestingly the Bahrain revolution is said to have started when a set of Google Earth images mapped the 'rich oases' dotting the landscape belonging to various members of the royal family. But then again we converge on the question how did access and visibility of water come to be an indicator of wealth in a democracy as well as spaces formed under dictatorial regimes?
 In present times where democracies have fascist policies and fascists hide behind veils of charities the boundaries often get blurred between the two, with similar requirements expected from the design of urban form like mass subjugation, crowd control, securing class struture through segregated class based developments and finally designing social condensers. 
As a joke, I like to believe that out there in some office or a university our favourite underpaid intern is working on a street section or a built form typology after which the world will never be the same...

Saturday, April 23, 2011

Collective Memories


(images sourced from here, which has some more of Corinne Vionnet's works)
Every monument has a postcard and every postcard has its monument that can be viewed and recognised instantly by eyes of friends and family that may never visit it. But through the circulation of these postcards across the globe, not only the monument but even the vantage point from where to record it best have become a part of some sort of a collective memory of the 'networked' population of the human race.

(images sourced from here, which has some more of Corinne Vionnet's works)
Or maybe it isn't the postcards but it is the arrangement of the space that through the axes and imaginary lines that diverge from the subject makes certain angles universally comprehensive to the human eye constrained by its range of colour spectrum, cone of vision or depth of field and appealing to the mind that composes these invisible influences of space within the canvas of the frame.

(images sourced from here, which has some more of Corinne Vionnet's works)
We can not really say if it is the postcards or the space that have come to institutionalise the points of best views around monuments, but what we can say is when Switzerland-based artist Corinne Vionnet overlaps 200 to 300 photographs of the same monument taken by tourists across the world the result is a set of exquisitely ephemeral looking images of collective human memory. Some images where the frames record changes, they act like compact time-capsules recording changes as new silhouettes come into focus and older ones fade away.
The nature of images reminded me of Leonardo da Vinci's The Virgin and Child with St Anne and St John the Baptist charcoal sketch from the National Gallery that gets built through tedious layers of strokes that attempt to find the right form in the white space, while the area of focus or rather confidence stays clean, the hand that points skyward;
(photo of Taj Mahal with scaffoldings sourcedhere. The site also has photos of many more porcupined fuzzy looking buildings in various stages of existence)
Like humanity formulating these monuments through scaffoldings of collective memories.